Skip to Content

Sarah Jaffe: NY Attorney General Schneiderman Removed From Foreclosure Settlement Group For Doing His Job

Bookmark and Share

As scrutiny intensifies on Bank of America and pressure for a settlement mounts, Schneiderman isn’t backing down.

By **Sarah Jaffe**

By arrangement with

sarahjaffeprofile.jpgWhile most of the federal and state governments seem willing to go along with a pretty weak settlement over the massive foreclosure crisis and sign away any right to get restitution from the big banks, New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman is pressing for a better deal.

He’s not alone, of course. Beau Biden of Delaware and Martha Coakley of Massachusetts have also signaled interest in continuing investigations after a settlement.

But Iowa Attorney General Tom Miller has singled out Schneiderman, removing him from a “leadership role” in the settlement talks. An executive committee of 13 attorneys general, now not including Schneiderman, is leading the negotiations with the banks, supposedly on behalf of all 50 states.

One might think New York’s AG would have a special interest in being closely involved with a settlement that involves Wall Street. But Miller referred to Schneiderman’s concerns about the settlement as “undermining our effort.”

Schneiderman’s spokesman said, “Ongoing investigations by attorneys general cannot be shut down by efforts to settle quickly and those responsible must be held accountable. While it is Attorney General Miller’s prerogative to remove us from the executive committee, we will continue to be an active voice on these issues as a part of the 50-state coalition and in other forums.”

And Marcy Wheeler notes that the attacks on Schneiderman seem to intensify as does the Bank of America death spiral.

She writes:

“[Y]ou can’t separate the ongoing pressure on Schneiderman from the underlying issue—whether the analysis which BoA used, which depended on their own internal review of completely incomparable files, to declare themselves solvent is valid.

Because what Schneiderman is insisting on doing, both in the $8.5 billion proposed securitization settlement and the $20 billion proposed servicing settlement, is to try to look at the files.

Schneiderman is insisting on doing the analysis that BoA’s handpicked analyst didn’t do.

The attorney general… is living up to his reputation and refusing to back down under attacks from the banks and pressure from the Obama administration.

Now what do you suppose it means that BoA’s surrogates have gotten so angry and panicked and, well, dickish, as Schneiderman continues to insist on actually looking at BoA’s books before making a settlement with them? And do you really think it’s a coinkydink that increasing numbers of Wall Street vultures are raising doubts about what’s in those books at precisely the time Obama’s surrogates are increasing pressure on Schneiderman to drop the legal efforts to do so?”

As the attacks on Schneiderman increase, progressive groups are coming out in support. In a statement released by the group The New Bottom Line, activists express support for the New York AG’s efforts.

“Scheiderman was the first AG to say that he wasn’t going to back down on the big banks, and he was the first AG kicked out of the investigation,” said Judy Lonning, a member of Iowa Citizens for Community Improvement. “There’s no question who this decision favors. It’s all about making life better for the big banks.”

And Schneiderman sent an email to his supporters [Thursday] afternoon, saying, “I am deeply committed to pursuing a full investigation into the misconduct that led to the collapse of America’s housing market, and to seeking a resolution that gives homeowners meaningful relief, allows the housing market to begin to recover, and gets our economy moving again.”

The attorney general praised by progressives like Katrina vanden Heuvel and supported by the Working Families Party is living up to his reputation and refusing to back down under attacks from the banks and pressure from the Obama administration.


This post originally appeared at

Sarah Jaffe is an associate editor at AlterNet, a rabblerouser and frequent Twitterer. You can follow her at @seasonothebitch.

  Rebecca Solnit: Hope: The Care and Feeding Of: How it will all end is anybody’s guess, but the future remains wide open. You just have to open your eyes. More
  Robert Reich: Stock Tip: Be Worried. Workers Are Consumers: It was only a matter of time before the boom on Wall Street turned into a bust. More
  Robert Reich: The Biggest Driver in the Deficit Battle: Standard & Poor’s: Who is Standard & Poor’s to tell America how much debt it has to shed in order to keep its credit rating? More
  Noam Chomsky: Is the World Too Big to Fail?: The Contours of Global Order: If public opinion were to influence policy, the U.S. not only would not control the region, but would be expelled from it. More


Readers like you make Guernica possible. Please show your support.

Tagged with:

You might also like

Comments are temporarily closed