Skip to Content

Shazia Yousuf: The Hidden Damage

In the 1990s, as Kashmiri men fighting Indian occupation were tortured and killed, Kashmiri women silently suffered through a different kind of war.

https://www.guernicamag.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/5166831476_218b60c147_z.jpg
Image from Kashmir Global via Flickr

By Shazia Yousuf

The soldiers had just left and my grandmother’s house looked battered and bruised. Cupboards and chests lay open like fresh wounds, bleeding secrets of the family that were neatly kept between books and folded clothes.

It was a crackdown, a routine search operation that Indian soldiers carried out to catch Kashmiri men who had taken up arms to fight the Indian occupation in 1989. Soldiers would pick a random location on a random day and ask men to assemble in front of a group of masked informers. Whenever an informer pointed his finger at someone, the person was bundled into a military vehicle and taken to an unknown location for torture or death.

Kashmiri girls are expected to live in mystery.

Men detested crackdowns. They hated being at the mercy of an unknown masked man. Women hated them too. Not because they had to face soldiers all alone during the house to house searches for militants and arms. Not because the soldiers turned things upside down and left the houses in disorder and chaos. There was a different reason.

When the crackdown was just over at my grandmother’s house and soldiers were leaving the neighborhood with the identified men, my young aunt rushed upstairs with her friend. I was a little girl, around seven and it was the first crackdown I was witnessing at my maternal home. I curiously followed my aunt and her friend as they climbed the narrow staircase.

Around a dozen sanitary pads lay scattered in my aunt’s room. Her cupboard drawers lay emptied on her bed, revealing everything that was in them: her fancy lingerie, scissors, tweezers, and beauty creams. My aunt looked miserable, as if she had lost a battle. A whole bunch of unknown men had just left her house, gossiping and giggling about the secrets she so wanted to hide.

“They played a different kind of war with us. Only they knew where they pinched; only we knew how it felt. There was no name for it, like for rape or murder.”

“Looks like the bastards had a great time,” my aunt said to her friend, her eyes frozen at something unknown. “Their faces said it all.”

I had almost forgotten about this incident until recently when I went to see my aunt and her newly adopted baby girl. I wanted to see what my forty-something aunt was doing with all the happiness that the child brought to her home. Childlessness had made her quiet and sad and she looked much older than her age. When I saw her from distance, she was talking to this five-days-old child and laughing at the blank stares she received in response. She looked frail but energetic. There was something unusual about her dark circled eyes. They were twinkling with joy.

“I was telling her to be brave and bold and not weak or shy like me,” my aunt said when I reached near and asked what the conversation was about.

Her mention of shyness took me back to her room, where she sat blushing amid sanitary pads and lingerie. I could clearly see my aunt tired of losing yet another battle. Curious, I wanted to know more about how young women felt in those war times and what war meant to them. I began interviewing my aunt.

“They played a different kind of war with us. Only they knew where they pinched; only we knew how it felt. There was no name for it, like for rape or murder,” she said.

From eating the predawn meal to breaking fast, from doing ablutions to offering prayers, women simulate every act to leave men clueless.

Kashmir is a conservative and patriarchal society. Men go out to earn; women stay indoors to take care of the house and children. The mingling of young boys and girls is considered immoral and is highly discouraged. Girls who remain invisible and avoid men’s gazes are believed to be pure and chaste. The honor of a family is thought to be in the hands of its daughters.

Kashmiri girls are expected to live in mystery. No male member of her family should ever see her intimate clothes. They should not be able to guess the timing of her periods. Although Islam exempts Muslim women from fasting and praying during their monthly cycles, almost every Kashmiri woman fakes these obligations in front of men. From eating the predawn meal to breaking fast, from doing ablutions to offering prayers, women simulate every act to leave men clueless. They fake smiles even when writhing in menstrual pain.

So what happened when the same women saw Indian soldiers playing with their intimate things and taking sexual pleasure under the guise of search operations? Did these women talk about this misuse of power? Did they tell their own men what they were going through? Were they ashamed? Angry?

“There was no culture of discussing these issues with our men. That made things worse because soldiers took advantage of it,” recalls my aunt.

My journalist friend once wrote a piece on the humiliation that the crackdowns brought to Kashmiri women. He described how a young girl from his village was forced to unlock a small box that soldiers found in her cupboard. There was no chance of weapons being hidden in it. But seeing the young girl blush, the soldiers became curious to know what it contained.

A number of love letters written in Urdu were taken from the box. The village leader, who was accompanying the soldiers, was made to read them aloud in front of all, including the girl.

“She was embarrassed in front of the old man who now knew about her affair and the boy she was dating,” my friend said. “She never showed him her face again.”

“I have no good memories of your birth,” my mother tells me. “It only reminds me of the horrors.”

That kind of humiliation was routine for Kashmiri women, who therefore made great efforts to avoid it. I was born three years before the armed war started in Kashmir, but at the time of my birth a fight between two political parties had resulted in the imposition of a curfew in Srinagar, my birthplace and the capital of Kashmir. The midwife had warned my mother of some complications and advised her to go to hospital for delivery. As my grandmother and other neighborhood women rehearsed in the courtyard for their journey to the hospital, my mother watched from a window. One of the women sat in front of an imaginary taxi, waved her hand at the imaginary soldiers, and shouted, “sir, please, delivery case.” Everyone liked the plan except for my mother. She did not like the idea of unknown soldiers looking at her belly on the street while she cried and perspired in labor.

In the end, I was born in my childhood home, without any medical assistance, in the same room where my elder siblings were born. “I have no good memories of your birth,” my mother tells me. “It only reminds me of the horrors.”

As I grew up, I began making sense of the conflict around me, but it took me a while to realize how the presence of soldiers caused distress and anxiety for women in our conservative society, forced them to suffer and grieve in silence.

My great aunt lived close to our house and my sister and me were addicted to the company of her two daughters, my mother’s cousins, who spun pashmina and watched us dance as the radio played old Bollywood numbers. The younger sister was secretly in a love affair with a distant relative who was also an active militant. One day when a crackdown was announced and men were asked to assemble for identification, the militant came running to my great aunt’s house and asked for refuge. When soldiers came to search the house, he managed to hide in a room where my mother’s cousins sat spinning wool, attempting to divert the soldiers’ attention.

They found him and emptied around a dozen bullets into his chest. The girls watched, stone-faced, as his blood made patterns on the mud floor. He died within seconds.

Afterward, my mother’s cousin skillfully gave fake smiles and acted normal during the day. But at night, as I slept between her and her sister, I could hear her sobbing in the dark. Her sister often told me not to pay attention and concentrate on my sleep. In other words she would tell me to let her do what she couldn’t do during day.

Things have begun to change, though slowly. Last year in May, a group of fifty Kashmiri women—including doctors, students, social activists, and house wives—came together and signed a petition demanding a fresh probe into the mass rape that took place in the village of Kunan-Poshpora on the night of February 23, 1990. Soldiers in the Indian army raped forty Kashmiri women during a search operation that night. The government hushed up the case and gave clean chits to the army men despite having solid evidence against them.

Twenty-three years of injustice had left the victims hopeless. But when the petitioners visited them, listened to their stories, and encouraged them to not to give up fighting, they started their struggle afresh. For the first time since the attacks, the victims traveled to Srinagar and made media appearances.

That moment offers fresh hope, but it almost didn’t occur. Ifra Butt, a social activist with The Jammu and Kashmir Coalition of Civil Society (JKCCS) and one of the founding members of the support group that started the petition, told me how hard it was to convince the victims to take up the fight. Faced with their reluctance to speak about their experiences in public, Butt told the women that there was no shame in facing the world and telling people what happened that night. And if there was any, it was our collective shame and not theirs alone.

Shazia Yousuf lives in Kashmir. She holds a Master’s in Mass Communication and Journalism from the University of Kashmir and a Master’s in Print and Multimedia Journalism from Emerson College. She was recently awarded the Panos South Asia fellowship and will be writing about Kashmiri women and their perspective of war.

Readers like you make Guernica possible. Please show your support.

Tagged with:

You might also like

7 comments for Shazia Yousuf: The Hidden Damage

  1. Comment by Vivek Iyer on October 2, 2014 at 12:08 pm

    This reminds me of the time my eighty year old mother was humiliated by people in uniform at Heathrow airport. They even confiscated her small pen knife with which she cut up apples. How long must women be humiliated and shamed in this way? There is a pervasive culture of shame whereby every time terrorists carry out a massacre, people feel ashamed to speak out at the manner in which they are humiliated by so called ‘Security forces’. Previously only high status males- like Nobel Laureate Amartya Sen who was questioned by Immigration authorities at Heathrow- who made a song and dance about these things. it is a sign of the tremendous progress that Kashmiri women have made over the last twenty years that they are at last speaking out about how disgusting their men-folk are. Gayatri Spivak Charkrovorty, in her seminal essay, ‘can the subaltern speak’ mentions a great-aunt of hers who hanged herself while menstruating in a manner that deconstructed prevailing binaries of ‘purity” and ‘silliness’. Germaine Greer, in her path breaking ‘the female Eunuch’ suggested that not till women taste their own menstrual blood will true niceness be achieved in an environmentally sustainable and manner.

  2. Comment by Mohammed on October 3, 2014 at 11:49 am

    Kashmir can never be complete without my fellow Pandits. This article completely ignored the plight of my Hindu brothers who were raped, molested & thrown out of their homes. Who can forgot the call of the Imams to the Pandits to leave their homes, yet leave the women behind?

  3. Comment by ModernDesi on October 3, 2014 at 12:25 pm

    It doesn’t put into context the fact that the 90s rebellion was not purely Kashmiri. It was fueled by the the trained militants emboldened by the victory against the Russians in Afghanistan. Does it point out that these men in uniform who’re ready to give up their lives for the country for pittance live under a literally constant threat to their lives. Once caught, they’re beheaded, brutally mutilated and made an example out of. I agree of course, women had it rough and I would hate to see the women in my house to go through any of this but please let’s not forget political context when we write political articles. Also, it’ll be interesting to compare the track record of countries with other countries. Pakistan savagely oppressed Bangladesh when they should’ve made Rehman the PM. USA and UK in Iraq have caused the greatest injustice in Iraq. These things in Kashmir are very unfortunate and no way to live a dignified life. The government has invested 8000 crore for infrastructure. 1000 crore for flood relief. Not enough but guys let’s be constructive and move forward. Vent out your grievances but also be fair. The Hindus of Bangladesh and the Muslims of Iraq are the other two references that you have to compare to. Indian government does deserve some credit in a terrorist infested area.

  4. Comment by ess kay on October 3, 2014 at 2:39 pm

    Well written, honest prose. Eager to see the next installment from this Kashmiri writer.

    P.S. Vivek, you’re an idiot.

  5. Comment by Asif wani on October 3, 2014 at 2:49 pm

    soo true!!..um speechless….hav no words 2 say.
    🙁

  6. Comment by Jasir on October 6, 2014 at 2:56 pm

    The wounds of actions in Kashmir by rogue and communal armed forces are fresh in our hearts and minds. It will continue serving as a tool of hatred against India and Indian occupation for generations. The young generation of writers like Shazia have and are documenting every event that will provide a proof to the world community in order to declare India more fascist and communal than Nazis and other brute nations in history.
    I pity the readers who term the write-ups as fiction or prose. I also pity the Pandit or Pandit supporters who wishes to drag their so called plight in the story. Pandits in fact were advised to leave the Valley in order to facilitate brute forces to fire left, right and centre only to kill the members of a particular community- more than 100000 of whom killed by them. Let Pandits support our demand for an independent international probe into the migration of their community.

  7. Comment by Anita Kotha Thompson on October 9, 2014 at 11:47 am

    Shazia Yousuf, I congratulate you on fellowship award and hope you will make good use of this platform. I read your article with keen interest as I happen to be a Kashmiri, was born and brought up in Rainawari, Srinagar, where I spent formidable years of my youth. My forefathers were also born and had lived in the valley of Kashmir- just like yours.
    You write about the war that Kashmiri men had taken up against Indian soldiers in fighting Indian occupation. The very fact that you are writing about a war, you should know that sexual assault and sex crimes are tools of war and very effective tools of war – meant to provoke on many levels. We, as women, should condemn this tool of war. Unfortunately, the barbaric crimes committed even as I write this comment by Islamic State against women, non-Muslims men and women – savage crimes committed and videotaped for the rest of the world to watch do continue to happen.
    In that bigger context, Islamic State had arrived in Kashmir in 1989. You only write about your side of the war. You conveniently omit the other savage, brutal, barbaric murder and slaughter of thousands of ethnic Kashmiri Hindus at the hands of same Muslim men that had taken up arms against Indian army. Kashimiri Hindu minority men were brutally killed, their dead bodies dragged and sweets showered over the dead bodies. They didn’t live to see their laundry, and lingerie disturbed, they were not given a chance, taken away from their loved ones and their children so early and brutally.
    Do you recall loudspeakers spewing hatred instead of prayers on Jan 19, 1990? Facebook and ipone era had not arrived in 1990, so there may not be videotapes of muders and slaughters at the hands of Muslims, there are written accounts of some on Kashmir Times. Check on what happened to your neighbors who happened to not subscribe to you faith. I ask you to explore and answer those questions and write intellectually honest accounts of a war that you are purporting to write about.
    Also, having also grown in Kashmir, my memories of Indian army stationed there was as saviors, protecting us from savages that had attacked our state in 1947. My father worked in may border towns and we saw them as only protectors.
    Thanks,
    Anita

Leave a comment




Anti-Spam Quiz:

Subscribe without commenting