We're extremely proud that Guernica has been free to read every day for 11 years. Consider supporting this work with a donation to the little non-profit magazine that could!

Skip to Content

Katie Halper: Christians, send your Jewish friends ‘thank you for Christmas’ greeting cards

December 26, 2008

I would like to give birth to a new holiday tradition. Forget the Happy Hanukkah cards. How about a thank you note?

mary good

Who killed Jesus is a topic of much debate: was it the Jews, the Romans, a combination, Jesus’s own father, a plot requirement? Yet the question of who gave birth to baby Jesus is answered without equivocation: Mary. Yes, she did so with the help of God, but it was Mary who schlepped from inn to inn before settling on a perfectly acceptable no-frills manger (a real find). And it was her zaftig child bearing hips which really delivered the goods. I happen to like Jesus, who was a real mensch, and wish that the Church followed his teachings more closely. And I’m not trying to take all the Jewish credit for Christ’s birth. I just think that since we have, throughout history, been blamed for his death, we deserve, at the very least, a a little credit for his birth. So here are some sample cards I would like to see. Nothing fancy, don’t go crazy. Just something like "Thanks so much for the best Christmas present ever… Jesus Christ!!!" Or "We were thrilled with a lord. But a lord AND savior! You really outdid yourself." So Christians, send a thank you note to every Tom, Dick and Harry–or Tov, Dov, and Heschie–you know.

Readers like you make Guernica possible. Please show your support.

You might also like

Leave a comment




Anti-Spam Quiz:

Subscribe without commenting