Bookmark and Share

Japan has committed to building an entirely new, less nuclear-reliant energy policy. Maybe we should consider doing the same.

By **Russ Baker**

By arrangement with WhoWhatWhy.Com.

Great to have the country’s leader boldly pledge to “start from scratch” in creating a new energy policy.

Great if you’re Japanese.

As reported by the New York Times,

     Prime Minister Naoto Kan said Tuesday that Japan would abandon plans to build new

     nuclear reactors, saying his country needed to “start from scratch” in creating a new

     energy policy.

     …Tuesday’s decision will abandon a plan that the Kan government released

     last year to build 14 more nuclear reactors by 2030 and increase the share of

     nuclear power in Japan’s electricity supply to 50 percent. Japan currently has 54

     reactors that before the earthquake produced 30 percent of its electricity.

     The cancellation of the planned nuclear plants is the second time that Mr.

     Kan has suddenly announced big changes in Japanese nuclear policy

     without the usual endless committee meetings and media leaks that

     characterize the country’s consensus-driven decision making. Mr. Kan

     appears to be seeking a stronger leadership role after criticism of his government’s

     sometimes slow and indecisive handling of the Fukushima accident.

     Last week, Mr. Kan asked a utility company to suspend operations at the Hamaoka

     nuclear plant, which sits atop an active earthquake fault line, about 120 miles

     southwest of Tokyo. After three days of delays, the company, Chubu Electric Power,

     finally agreed on Monday to shut down the plant until a new wave wall was built and

     other measures could be taken to strengthen it against earthquakes and tsunamis.

     Mr. Kan said Japan would retain nuclear and fossil fuels as energy sources, but vowed

     to add two new pillars to Japan’s energy policy: renewable energy and

     conservation. While Japan has been a global leader in energy conservation,

     it lags behind the United States and Europe in adopting solar and wind

     power, and other new energy sources.

     “We need to start from scratch,” Mr. Kan told reporters. “We need to make nuclear

     energy safer and do more to promote renewable energy.”

What’s striking here is that the Japanese are taking this responsible action even though (or perhaps because) they are desperate for ways of generating energy. Unlike the U.S., Japan has very few natural resources, and is hugely dependent on imports and self-generated sources, principally nuclear.

The point here is that Japan is worth looking at because it is a much more advanced model of where we all may be before too long.

Also striking is that the Japanese have already been remarkably responsible in so many ways. The waste and consumption of the typical Japanese person is much smaller than an American in almost every category.

The United States is (or was—data not that recent) #11 in per capita electric energy consumption (the biggest users tend to be extremely cold and hot countries, with severe energy needs) at 12,747 kilowatts; Japan is #23 at 7,701 kilowatts per capita. The U.S. is #17 in natural gas consumption at 2.168 million cubic meters per 1000 population; Japan is #47 at 787,000 cubic meters. The U.S. is #5 in per capita coal consumption, at 3.58 tons of coal; Japan is #12 at 1.17.

Shall I stop yet? How about oil? “USA #1!” takes on a whole new meaning at 8.35 tons of “oil equivalent” per capita. Japan is #11 at 4.13.

     Mr. Kan had also previously called for Japan to sell its nuclear technology to emerging

     nations as a new source of export income. However, the Fukushima accident has

     prompted a global rethinking of nuclear energy and may drive customers away from

     Japanese suppliers to rivals in places like South Korea.

     Mr. Kan also appeared to pull back from his earlier vows to remain committed to

     nuclear power. His apparent about-face may be driven partly by public opinion, which

     has soured on nuclear power since the Fukushima accident…

The point here is that Japan is worth looking at because it is a much more advanced model of where we all may be before too long. Japan is finding out that importing fossil fuels is not the way to go, and neither is nuclear. Conservation they’re pretty good at, and it’s still not enough.

Not long ago, WhoWhatWhy reprinted an article based on an intriguing study aimed at achieving 100 percent renewable energy. As expected, some folks were off the blocks with criticism of why this couldn’t be done. But most readers reacted with genuine excitement at the idea of at least making a concerted effort to do something along these lines. And a new study from the UN says that at least 80 percent renewable energy is a viable prospect.

The real problem is a lack of political will and guts. Maybe our leaders can learn something from the Japanese.

As for the average American, we have to do a lot better in educating (or shaming) our fellow citizens when it comes to reckless lifestyles. Anyone who has traveled a bit around this country knows (and anyone who has traveled elsewhere is struck by the contrast) just how childishly extravagant we can be. We’re about the biggest litterers anywhere. We just have to have the latest and biggest monstrosities, from vehicles to flat screens. Everything has to be triple-packed, and 40 napkins, please. Leave the TV on all day to keep the house company. Maintenance of acres of green lawn. On and on.

The United States is #1 in the amount of municipal waste per capita. Japan is #21. Japanese generate 400 kilos of waste per person; Americans, 720.

Maybe a delegation of (slightly irradiated) Japanese, like gentle aliens in some Spielberg movie, can arrive on our shores to point us to a more thoughtful and harmonious way of getting along with Mother Earth.


Copyright 2011 Russ Baker


By arrangement with WhoWhatWhy.Com.

  Joshua Frank: Why Climate Activist George Monbiot Has Gone Nuclear—And Why He’s Wrong

“I am no longer nuclear-neutral.” More

  Tom Engelhardt: The Worst That Could Happen: The author reflects on the Fukushima nightmare. More
  Norman Solomon: Nuclear Power Madness: With the nuclear meltdowns in Japan, it’s up to us to peacefully and insistently shut our U.S. plants down. More
  Rebecca Solnit: Unpacking for a Disaster: What You Need to Survive the Unexpected: In the wake of its present disaster, Japan may already be changing, and that may not be a bad thing.


For more on this topic and others at GUERNICA, click HERE .


At Guernica, we’ve spent the last 15 years producing uncompromising journalism.

More than 80% of our finances come from readers like you. And we’re constantly working to produce a magazine that deserves you—a magazine that is a platform for ideas fostering justice, equality, and civic action.

If you value Guernica’s role in this era of obfuscation, please donate.

Help us stay in the fight by giving here.

Read Next